top of page
Writer's pictureEvelyn Ball

Emotional Signals and the Medicalization of Mental and Physical Health

Updated: Nov 19

Imagine if a doctor prescribed alcohol to manage anxiety or insomnia. A drink might help you feel relaxed, more social, and even aid in falling asleep.


Of course, this sounds absurd. We know that relying on alcohol for these purposes leads to significant problems—dependence, health risks, and harm to relationships and well-being. While alcohol temporarily numbs emotional pain and reduces self-expectations, it ultimately sabotages long-term health and growth.


Now, consider the widespread use of psychotropic medications like Zoloft, Cymbalta, and Prozac. These drugs alter brain chemistry and can mask emotional pain without addressing its root causes. They’re often presented as quick fixes for complex emotional experiences, but at what cost?


The Problem with Quick Fixes

In today’s culture, we rush to label and medicalize normal emotional responses. Diagnoses like anxiety, depression, and ADHD dominate conversations—even among teenagers. This trend reflects a societal desire to eliminate discomfort quickly, prioritizing productivity and societal approval over true emotional health.


But humans are complex. We are intricate beings, and our emotions serve a vital purpose. Feelings of stress, sadness, and fear are signals meant to guide us toward change—whether that’s adjusting our environment, behaviors, or relationships. Ignoring these signals or dulling them with medication is like silencing the fire alarm while the fire still burns.


As Gabor Maté explains in The Myth of Normal, the problem isn’t that our signals are faulty—it’s that our environment is out of balance. The rise in mental health diagnoses mirrors the unhealthy conditions of modern life: overstimulation, disconnection, isolation, and relentless pressure to perform.


Listening to Our Signals

Our symptoms are not enemies - they are messengers urging us to make changes. They invite us to:

  • Reassess our relationships and boundaries

  • Adjust our daily habits and routines

  • Prioritize rest, movement, and nourishing food

  • Reduce our exposure to overstimulating content and environments


These simple, natural strategies often go overlooked in favor of quick pharmaceutical solutions. Yet, as many have experienced, small lifestyle changes—like getting more sleep, increasing our mobility, or spending time in nature—can profoundly impact our mental and emotional well-being.


My Personal Experience

Several years ago, I found myself struggling with exhaustion and daytime drowsiness. When I brought this up with my doctor, her immediate suggestion was Ritalin. No deeper questions, no exploration of potential lifestyle factors—just a quick prescription for a quick fix.


Instead of accepting the medication, I chose to reflect on my habits. I improved my sleep routine, adjusted my diet, and worked on reducing stress. Within days, the drowsiness disappeared. While most cases are not this straightforward, it underscores an important point: natural solutions can’t be found if we’re not even looking for them.


A Call to Rethink Mental Health

Let me be clear: medication can play a critical role in acute or severe cases. But we need to be cautious about turning to pharmaceuticals as the first or only solution. There are countless holistic strategies—rooted in the mind-body connection—that empower us to heal naturally and strengthen our bodies and our emotional system.


In today’s world, overstimulation and disconnection are constant. We wake up to screens, scroll through endless content, and fall asleep to the glow of our devices. These habits contribute to anxiety, depression, ADHD, and more. Should we really label and medicate our symptoms when they are actually natural responses to an overwhelming environment? Or do we want to take a different approach?


Rather than suppressing these responses with medication, we can listen to them. By tuning into our emotional and physical signals, we can make thoughtful changes that foster resilience and true well-being.


The Bigger Picture

Many mental health professionals are raising concerns about the long-term risks of psychotropic medications, particularly when they’re used as substitutes for addressing relational and environmental factors. When we pathologize normal reactions to trauma and stress, we overlook the root causes—and the opportunity to heal.


It’s time to reclaim our health. By quieting the noise of modern life and reconnecting with our inner wisdom, we can find and choose naturopathic strategies to foster meaningful, lasting change.


It’s never too late to start listening to your body, honoring but not leading by your emotions, and building a life rooted in genuine well-being.

5 views0 comments

Comments


bottom of page